Question
Does BMI work for muscular people?
Short answer
The NHS in the UK notes that BMI cannot tell muscle from fat. If you carry a lot of muscle, it may put you in the overweight or obese category without much body fat, so a muscular person can have a high BMI and you should not rely on BMI alone. Lifters say BMI is useless.
What this is based on
- The NHS says people from Black African or African-Caribbean backgrounds are at risk of health problems at a slightly lower BMI: 23 to 27.4 is overweight and 27.5 or more is obese. Lose weight steadily, about half to one kilogram a week, with a balanced diet and activity. BMI cannot tell muscle from fat.From the card's plain answer
- Relying on BMI alone if you carry a lot of muscle: it may put you in the overweight or obese category without much body fat.Clinical guidance NHS, "Overweight and obesity in adults"
- Being bigger is often seen as healthy or attractive in many families, and weight comments are common. Lifters say BMI is useless.Tradition and common belief, not evidence
- The NHS uses lower BMI thresholds for adults from South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African or African-Caribbean backgrounds: overweight from 23, obese from 27.5. Steady loss of about half to one kilogram a week, a balanced diet, less alcohol and activity are the NHS advice. The NHS also notes BMI cannot tell muscle from fat. I opened no study testing the cut-offs in Black adults.From the card
Also asked as
- is bmi accurate for muscular people
- is bmi accurate for muscle
- is bmi accurate for people who lift weights
- is bmi accurate for weight lifters
- Is BMI accurate if you are muscular?
- Can a muscular person have a high BMI?
From the card
The NHS says people from Black African or African-Caribbean backgrounds are at risk of health problems at a slightly lower BMI: 23 to 27.4 is overweight and 27.5 or more is obese. Lose weight steadily, about half to one kilogram a week, with a balanced diet and activity. BMI cannot tell muscle from fat.
Where this comes from
- Agyemang 2012 (Study page) Open source
- NHS, "Overweight and obesity in adults" Open source
Read the full entry: Weight, BMI and losing weight safely
Last checked against its sources: . Next check due: 17 May 2027.
This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence.