Weight, BMI and losing weight safely

How do I lose weight or tone up safely?

  • Tier D Untested
  • Last checked
  • Not yet clinically reviewed

The answer

The NHS says people from Black African or African-Caribbean backgrounds are at risk of health problems at a slightly lower BMI: 23 to 27.4 is overweight and 27.5 or more is obese. Lose weight steadily, about half to one kilogram a week, with a balanced diet and activity. BMI cannot tell muscle from fat.

Do

Avoid

In other countries

Official advice differs between countries. These lines were checked against each body's own page on the date shown.

  • In the US, NIDDK defines overweight as a BMI of 25 to 29.9 and obesity as 30 or above for adults. Source page dated date not clear; 'Last reviewed May 2023' shown
  • WHO defines adult overweight as a BMI of 25 or more and obesity as 30 or more. Source page dated 7 Oct 2026

Last checked 17 November 2026.

What families do

Tradition and common belief, not evidence.

Being bigger is often seen as healthy or attractive in many families, and weight comments are common. Lifters say BMI is useless.

The evidence

The NHS uses lower BMI thresholds for adults from South Asian, Chinese, other Asian, Middle Eastern, Black African or African-Caribbean backgrounds: overweight from 23, obese from 27.5. Steady loss of about half to one kilogram a week, a balanced diet, less alcohol and activity are the NHS advice. The NHS also notes BMI cannot tell muscle from fat. I opened no study testing the cut-offs in Black adults.

This tier rests on: That the lower BMI cut-offs fit Black African and African-Caribbean adults: NHS statement only; I opened no study that tests them.

Why this tier and strength: D because the claim is NHS guidance and my search for the evidence behind it found nothing in the pages I opened; the one B line is about BMI differences, not about cut-offs. Would move with the NICE evidence review.

What has been tested

  1. B 22,723 adults in the Health Surveys for England (1,379 African-Caribbean) (n=22723)

    Secondary analysis of cross-sectional surveys of blood pressure and BMI.

    African-Caribbean women had higher BMI than white women; there was little difference in BMI in men.

    Agyemang C, Humphry RW, Bhopal R (2012), American Journal of Hypertension, [primary] Open source Study page

    Note: Included only for the BMI pattern; this paper does not test the NHS BMI cut-offs.

Harm

No signal found: No harm signal found for steady weight loss. Rapid loss is advised against by the UK's NHS.

Measured variables

  • BMI (weight divided by height squared); waist and body fat are alternatives not covered
  • Ethnic background, used by the NHS to set the cut-off; the underlying variable (body fat at a given BMI) was not shown in what I opened

Not tested, and gaps

Untested or not opened: NICE (UK) NG246 evidence for the ethnic-specific BMI cut-offs (the page I opened did not show them); body composition at equal BMI in Black adults; weight-loss medicines and surgery in Black adults (the UK's NHS gives lower BMI thresholds for surgery, 37.5, or 32.5 to 37.4 with a related condition, but I opened no study); muscle gain and "toning". The "get active 45 to 60 minutes" line is NHS weight-loss advice, not the general 150-minute target.

All sources

  • Agyemang C, Humphry RW, Bhopal R (2012), American Journal of Hypertension, [primary] Open
  • NHS, "Overweight and obesity in adults", [official], practical advice (clinical guidance), opened 2026-11-12 Open

Common questions

How do I lose weight or tone up safely?

Lose weight steadily, about half to one kilogram a week, with a balanced diet and activity.

What BMI is healthy for a Black person?

The NHS says people from Black African or African-Caribbean backgrounds are at risk of health problems at a slightly lower BMI: 23 to 27.4 is overweight and 27.5 or more is obese.

Does BMI work for muscular people?

The NHS says people from Black African or African-Caribbean backgrounds are at risk of health problems at a slightly lower BMI: 23 to 27.4 is overweight and 27.5 or more is obese.

Last checked against its sources: . Next check due: 12 May 2027.

This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence.