Question

What is the difference between a keloid and a hypertrophic scar?

  • Tier B moderate Observed in Black populations
  • Last checked 2026-11-12
  • Not yet clinically reviewed

Short answer

A keloid grows beyond the original wound, whereas a thickened scar stays within it. This entry rests that difference on the British Association of Dermatologists wording alone, because the NHS (UK) page does not mention hypertrophic scars. If a scar is raised, itchy, painful or growing, see a dermatologist or doctor early, as treatment started early may stop it growing.

What this is based on

  • Untested: whether avoiding piercing, or piercing at a younger age, prevents keloids (the age finding is from people who already had keloids); which jewellery is safest; which treatment works best in Black patients specifically (the 2014 consensus is not specific to Black skin); home remedies. Not opened: Jacobs 2023 on clinical trial participation in keloid. 12 Nov (NHS page re-opened): the UK's NHS lists steroid injections, silicone, cryotherapy and laser but does not compare them, and does not mention hypertrophic scars, so keloid against hypertrophic scar rests on the BAD wording (a keloid grows beyond the original wound) alone; no source opened compares steroid injection with laser.Not tested, and gaps (from the card)
  • A scar is raised, growing beyond the original wound, itchy or painful (dermatologist or doctor, early).When to see someone
  • See a doctor early about a raised scar: treatment started early may stop it growing.Clinical guidance NHS, "Keloid scars"
  • Keloids are strongly genetic and much more common in people of African ancestry. Most piercing keloids in one small survey came from piercings after age 11, and people with a family history were advised to think carefully before piercing. Nobody has tested whether avoiding piercing prevents keloids; if one forms, early treatment is the consensus advice. The BAD patient hub adds that a keloid spreads beyond the original area of skin damage and can follow very minor damage such as an acne spot, which is how it differs from a thickened scar that stays within the wound.From the card

Also asked as

  • What can be mistaken for a keloid scar?

From the card

Keloids run in families and are much more common in people of African ancestry. Nobody has tested whether avoiding piercings prevents them, but the UK's NHS advises prone people to avoid piercings and tattoos. If one forms, early treatment is the advice.

Where this comes from

Read the full entry: Keloids and piercings

Last checked against its sources: . Next check due: 17 May 2027.

This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence.