Practice: Mind
Prayer and the church as mental health support
What people do
Turn to prayer, scripture, the pastor or the congregation when distressed, instead of or before therapy.
Why people say it works
Tradition and common belief, not evidence.
God is a source of strength; church is trusted, free and close.
Who documented it
Taylor RJ et al 2021, Soc Work Public Health, PMID 33378231 (National Survey of American Life) survey
National Survey of American Life: three in four African Americans and Black Caribbeans with a 12-month psychiatric disorder used prayer to cope; prayer especially important with generalised anxiety.
The evidence
Tier is the evidence for the claim people make, not for the practice being widespread.
B Religious interventions for depression
Meta-analysis of 8 RCTs (not Black-specific). Religious-based interventions gave superior effects to usual therapies; trials varied widely.
Strength: thin, trial-other-population. Religious-based interventions for depression, meta-analysis of RCTs, 2022, J Affect Disord, PMID 35500682
Harm
Positive as support; risk is when prayer replaces treatment for severe illness.
Gaps
- Trials not in Black populations.
- Black British data not opened.
This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence. All practices.