Practice: Hair
Tight braids, weaves and extensions on relaxed hair
What people do
Put in tight cornrows, braids or extensions as a protective, low-maintenance style for weeks at a time.
Why people say it works
Tradition and common belief, not evidence.
Protects the ends, saves daily styling and keeps hair "tucked away".
Who documented it
Cape Town adults, 874: women's traction alopecia was 31.7% and was 48% when the usual style was extensions attached to relaxed hair.
Cape Town schoolchildren: traction alopecia 9.4% overall, 17.1% in girls, higher with relaxed than natural hair.
London: hair was washed on average every 17.9 days, rising to 32.8 days when braided or in a weave; only 46.3% avoided braiding relaxed hair.
The evidence
Tier is the evidence for the claim people make, not for the practice being widespread.
B Traction alopecia risk
1,178 girls and women. Highest risk when traction added to relaxed hair (OR 3.47); only 18.9% of women with TA had never noticed hairdressing symptoms.
Strength: moderate, observational-black-population. Determinants of marginal traction alopecia in African girls and women, 2008, J Am Acad Dermatol, PMID 18694677
B Risk grading of styles
Review. High-, moderate- and low-risk styles; limited literature.
Strength: thin, observational-black-population. Haskin A, Aguh C 2016, J Am Acad Dermatol, PMID 27114262
Harm
Traction alopecia can become permanent scarring hair loss; tightness and hairline pain are the early signs.
Gaps
- Cross-sectional, no trial of loosening styles.
This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence. All practices.