Question
Why are Black patients' pain and symptoms taken less seriously?
Short answer
In US survey-experiments on white laypeople and white medical students and residents, half of a sample of the students and residents endorsed false beliefs about biological differences between Black and white people. Those who did rated a Black patient's pain lower and made less accurate treatment recommendations. Research backs your experience: it is not you. Say what the pain stops you doing and how it affects your life.
What this is based on
- Who was tested: White laypeople and white medical students and residents, US. What was found: Half of a sample of white medical students and residents endorsed false beliefs about biological differences between Black and white people. Those who did rated the Black patient's pain lower and made less accurate treatment recommendations; those who did not rated the Black patient's pain higher and showed no bias in treatment recommendations.Tested Hoffman 2016 Study page
- Research backs your experience. In US studies Black patients were less likely than white patients to be given painkillers, and many white trainee doctors held false beliefs about biological differences that went with lower pain ratings. It is not you. Prepare, describe what the pain stops you doing, and ask for a plan.From the card's plain answer
- Say what the pain stops you doing and how it affects your life; the doctor is expected to ask about this and to record your pain level.Clinical guidance NHS, "How to get NHS help for your pain"
Also asked as
- Why do doctors not believe Black people when we say we are in pain?
- Do doctors think Black people feel less pain?
From the card
Research backs your experience. In US studies Black patients were less likely than white patients to be given painkillers, and many white trainee doctors held false beliefs about biological differences that went with lower pain ratings. It is not you. Prepare, describe what the pain stops you doing, and ask for a plan.
Where this comes from
- Hoffman 2016 (Study page) Open source
- Lee 2019 (Study page) Open source
- Hirani 2024 (Study page) Open source
- NHS, "How to get NHS help for your pain" Open source
- NHS, "Appointments and bookings at your GP surgery" Open source
- NHS, "Register with a GP surgery" Open source
- Pain Concern (a UK pain charity), "Breaking Barriers #4: GP consultations" Open source
Read the full entry: Being believed by doctors, and pain
Last checked against its sources: . Next check due: 16 May 2027.
This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence.