Compare
Shea butter, cocoa butter or coconut oil
Three traditional fats, compared only from what the linked entries say.
| Option | What the evidence says | Tier | Harm | Entry |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shea butter | no controlled trial has tested plain shea butter on skin Whether it beats other moisturisers is untested. | Tier D | No harm flag set. No harm signal found in my search beyond rare contact allergy (a single case report, title only seen). | Shea butter |
| Cocoa butter | a trial of cocoa butter in pregnant women found it made no difference | Tier B moderate | No harm flag set. No harm from the creams themselves; the harm is laser in dark skin from an inexperienced provider (review), and retinoids in pregnancy (NHS in the UK). | Stretch marks and fading scars |
| Coconut oil | In the lab, coconut oil protected hair strands from protein loss, which is about the strand, not the scalp. | Tier D | No harm flag set. No harm signal found for oiling or greasing in what I read. | Scalp oiling and greasing |
Tier and harm are those of the linked entry as a whole, so rows that share an entry share its tier. Sentences in the evidence column are quoted from the entry.
Verdict
None of the three has been shown to beat another: plain shea is untested on skin, cocoa butter made no difference to stretch marks in one trial, and coconut oil's evidence is lab work on hair strands. The linked entries report no comparison between them.
Sources
- Shea butter (entry sources)
- Stretch marks and fading scars (entry sources)
- Scalp oiling and greasing (entry sources)
This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence. All comparisons.