Question
Do lung function tests use a different normal for Black people?
Short answer
Until recently, spirometry standards promoted equations that also used self-reported race and ethnicity, so for years the machine compared Black patients with a lower predicted normal than white patients. The American Thoracic Society (US) now recommends replacing them with race-neutral equations. Which equations UK, African, Caribbean and other national services use is something our search found no list of. Ask which equation was used for your result.
What this is based on
- A spirometry test measures how much air you can blow out in one breath. For years the machine compared Black patients with a lower predicted normal than white patients, which can hide lung disease. Guidelines now recommend one race-neutral set of equations. The test is still useful, and your symptoms matter as much as the number.From the card's plain answer
- Your result is compared with a predicted normal. Until recently, standards promoted equations that also used self-reported race and ethnicity.Clinical guidance ATS official statement, "Race and Ethnicity in Pulmonary Function Test Interpretation" (Bhakta et al. 2023, abstract)
- Who was tested: Official American Thoracic Society workshop (2021) and review of newer evidence. What was found: Current ATS standards promoted race- and ethnicity-specific reference equations; concern grew that this gives a false view of fixed differences and may mask differential exposures and norm health disparities. The statement recommends replacing them with race-neutral average reference equations, alongside a broader re-evaluation of how lung function tests are used for clinical, employment and insurance decisions, a call to include missing stakeholders, and a caution about uncertain effects and potential harms.Tested Bhakta 2023 Study page
- Not found or not opened: which equations UK, African, Caribbean and other national services use (my search found no list); the full text of Bhakta and Cai; evidence from African or Caribbean populations; whether race-neutral equations improve disease detection or outcomes (no trial found); a 2024 NEJM study named in earlier notes was not found by my search and is not cited.Not tested, and gaps (from the card)
- You were told your lung function is normal but you are still short of breath: ask which equation was used and whether other tests are needed (doctor or lung specialist).When to see someone
From the card
A spirometry test measures how much air you can blow out in one breath. For years the machine compared Black patients with a lower predicted normal than white patients, which can hide lung disease. Guidelines now recommend one race-neutral set of equations. The test is still useful, and your symptoms matter as much as the number.
Where this comes from
- Bhakta 2023 (Study page) Open source
- Bowerman 2023 (Study page) Open source
- Cai 2026 (Study page) Open source
- NHS, "Spirometry test" Open source
Read the full entry: Lung function tests and race correction in spirometry
Last checked against its sources: . Next check due: 17 May 2027.
This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence.