Question

Can a pulse oximeter miss low oxygen in Black patients?

  • Tier B moderate Observed in Black populations
  • Harm signal
  • Last checked 2026-11-12
  • Not yet clinically reviewed

Short answer

In 30,039 paired readings from US veterans in hospital, a reading of 92% or more hid blood oxygen below 88% in 19.6% of Black patients and 15.6% of White patients. Most patients were White, race came from records and skin tone was not measured. The authors say this could limit Black patients' access to oxygen.

What this is based on

  • Who was tested: 30,039 paired readings in general-care inpatients, Veterans Health Administration, 2013-2019 (21.6% from non-Hispanic Black patients). What was found: Among SpO2 readings of 92% or more, the unadjusted probability of occult hypoxaemia (SaO2 below 88%) was 15.6% in white patients and 19.6% in black patients (P<0.001, similar in adjusted models). The authors say this could limit access to oxygen and other treatment for black patients.Tested Valbuena 2022 Study page
  • Pulse oximeters shine light through the skin, and melanin changes how that light behaves. In a large US hospital study, readings that looked safe hid low blood oxygen more often in Black patients. A UK review says the devices are valuable and should not be dropped, but need to be tested on darker skin tones.From the card's plain answer

Also asked as

  • are pulse oximeters accurate for black people
  • is a pulse oximeter accurate for oxygen levels
  • how accurate are pulse oximeters for oxygen

From the card

Pulse oximeters shine light through the skin, and melanin changes how that light behaves. In a large US hospital study, readings that looked safe hid low blood oxygen more often in Black patients. A UK review says the devices are valuable and should not be dropped, but need to be tested on darker skin tones.

Where this comes from

Read the full entry: Pulse oximeters and dark skin

Last checked against its sources: . Next check due: 16 May 2027.

This is information, not medical advice. If you are worried, see a doctor or pharmacist. How we grade the evidence.